A tale of two court cases
Friday, December 5th, 2008Today is the day that the NFL Players Association gets their day in court to try and start the process of overturning these suspensions. I don’t know how that one will turn out. However, I hope common sense wins the day.
The other case is the conspiracy theorist case that is being heard by the Supreme Court on the issue of Obama being a natural born citizen. The justices are going to determine if they will hear the case or not. Personally I think the court will either vote 9-0 or 8-1 to not hear the case because it has no merit. Here is why.
A) Obama was born in Hawaii. The Governor of Hawaii has stated that they have the “long form” and that it is sealed.
B) The “certificate of live birth” has been verified by several sources. Under Hawaii law, that form can be used in a court of law as evidence that Obama was born in Hawaii. I have a feeling that the court would defer to the states when it comes to the record-keeping of who as born in that state.
C) We don’t follow the citizenship laws of other countries. One of the points made in the case being heard today is the idea that since Kenya allowed for all children of the people who resided in Kenya (when it became a country) to be automatically granted Kenyan citizenship. This citizenship expired if by 21 the child did not pledge an oath of allegiance to Kenya. So currently, Obama does not have dual citizenship. More important is that just because a country states that IT considers a person to be a citizen of that country, it doesn’t mean that the United States will concur. If this wasn’t the case, then every four years when we elected a President one of the countries who does not like us could just grant that President citizenship in their country and the person would no longer be able to serve because he would be a “dual citizen”. Conspiracy theorists tend to be stupid, but I am shocked that even they cannot see the logic behind that argument. The bottom line is that under US Law, a natural born citizen of this country cannot have his or her citizenship status eliminated without his/her consent. So if Kenya grants him citizenship, or if his parents filled out paperwork for him as a child in Indonesia, it doesn’t matter. He cannot lose his citizenship unless he specifically asked for it once he became 18. Period. End of story.
Of course, when the court rules today that the case has no merit, I am sure that the conspiracy theorists will not shut up about it (since we still hear about 9.11 being an inside job from the 9.11 truthers). And if Obama does provide the “long form” to the court and the court does rule that it is valid, I am sure that the conspiracy theorists will just say that the paperwork is fraudulent. Because at the end of the day, it is not the Constitution that matters to these people. What matters to them is stopping Obama from being President.
Update: I should have called this post “trial trifecta”. OJ will be sentenced today as well.
Update 2: OJ is going to Jail. No word on the Obama case.
Update 3: The judge ordered that Will Smith and Deuce can play this Sunday! h/t Jeffrey
Update 4: As I reported in another post, SCOTUS refused to hear the Obama case.
