I will preface this post by saying that with every storm that Louisiana encounters, we will learn from past mistakes and likely make new ones. This is part of the process of learning how to cope with things that are fairly unpredictable (like hurricanes) and make sure that when we do, we do so to the best of our ability.
The good:
A) Contraflow: Contraflow was awful with Ivan. It took me 8 hours to get to Grammercy from Kenner. Not good. It got better with Katrina, only 13 hours to Houston. With Gustav, I personally encountered no traffic (though I did leave early). I know some traffic existed but I believe it was better than last time. Of course, with landfall on a Monday and people scared of a Katrina like event, some (like me) started evacuating on Friday night because we could. I am unsure how many people would have left as early had the storm come on Wednesday. So kudos to Jindal and everyone else responsible for making that happen.
B) Evacuating: From what I saw, people who wanted to leave got to leave (regardless of their ability to get themselves out). The state even planned for pets to be evacuated as well. The fact that so many people got out was very impressive and while I don’t know when this new busing plan was planned, the implementation of it seemed to go as smoothly as you could expect and again, Kudos to Jindal and everyone else responsible for making it happen.
The bad:
Unemployment: Louisiana’s unemployment system was knocked out after Gustav. This effected both people on unemployment from before the storm and those who do not have work because of it. Part of Jindal’s reorganization of state government moved the Louisiana Department of Labor under the Louisiana Workforce Commission. Now, I am unsure how fault tolerant the system was previously. However, the entire system should not be handicapped by losing the central hub. Individual centers around the state could not process claims manually or otherwise save the information locally so people could process their claims. This seems like awfully poor planning to me. Perhaps Louisiana needs to consider some sort of backup system to be in place for all of its online resources to be available in the case of an emergency. We could either set up different hubs around the state, each having the ability to take over for whatever node goes down. We could also utilize some temporary servers outside Louisiana. Something should be done to make sure that all of Louisiana’s services are up and running so we can have seamless operation after a storm. This is something Jindal needs to work on.
Electricity: Really? That many people lost power for that long? Really? At one point only 2 Louisiana Parishes had 0 power loss. Even today there are parishes that are still mostly without power. When I pay as much as I do for power, I expect them to have the capability to respond to outages must faster than what they are doing. Their “fuel surcharge” costs are criminal as it is. The fact that there are so many people without power now is just pathetic and something needs to be done.
The ugly:
A) Shelters. This is where Bobby Jindal really dropped the ball. It is great that people got out. But when they got there, to have the deplorable conditions that existed at some of these shelters is inexcusable. Why wouldn’t all shelters have generators? Why would you choose shelters that had no avaiable showers and inadequate toilet space? And what really bothers me is quotes like this:
“If you’re gonna help, help me. Don’t send me to a place like this,” Brown said Tuesday, his eyes sunken in the industrial lights that stay on around the clock for security reasons. “I would rather ride it out without power at home. I’m only taking a few more days of this. I don’t care if I have to walk the highway back.”
So you know what this means? Because of the awful conditions in the shelters, this will make people less likely to evacuate in the future. Jindal should have made sure that the places people went to had better conditions. This is something that was not learned by our government after Katrina. We all remember the faces of people at the convention center. And while I am sure the conditions at the shelters were not that bad, they were still bad.
Premature un-evacuation: The Governor should have found alternate places to house the evacuees once he saw the problem. Instead, we started bringing people home when there was another major storm entering the gulf. How does that make any sense? I understand people being upset at the conditions the Government put them in but it was irresponsible to bring them back when there was a chance they would have to evacuate again. Chances are they would not have evacuated. So this was another poor decision by our Government. And while we may be escaping Ike, it was still not worth the risk.
Overall, I give Jindal a C. He passed, he got people out, and he learned from some past experiences. However, there are still many things that could have done better and had the storm been worse (or had Ike taken a turn northward) I think we would have some serious problems.